Compliance

What Needs to Be in Your Employee Files (and What Doesn't)

May 21, 2025

If your employee files live in a filing cabinet drawer, a shared drive folder called "HR stuff," or somebody's inbox, you're not alone. But incomplete or disorganized files cost more than people expect. They slow down audits, weaken your position if a termination is challenged, and turn a simple question into a two-hour search.

The bigger issue, though, is usually not what's missing. It's what's in the wrong place.

The Personnel File

This is the main file for each employee, and it should hold the documents that describe their job and their history with you:

  • Offer letter or employment agreement
  • Current job description
  • Signed handbook and policy acknowledgments
  • Performance reviews, goals, and development plans
  • Disciplinary documentation, including written summaries of verbal warnings
  • Records of pay changes, promotions, and title changes
  • Training records and certifications
  • Separation documents, if applicable

What Must Be Kept Separate

Medical information

Anything with health information goes in a separate, confidential medical file with restricted access. That includes doctor's notes, FMLA certifications, accommodation requests and documentation, and anything related to workers' compensation. This isn't just good practice. Federal law requires employee medical information to be kept confidential and separate from the general personnel file.

Form I-9

Keep all I-9s together in their own file, not in individual personnel files. If there's ever an inspection, you hand over the I-9 file and nothing else.

Payroll and tax forms

W-4s, direct deposit forms, and garnishment orders are usually best kept with payroll records rather than mixed into the personnel file.

A Michigan-Specific Note

Under Michigan's Bullard-Plawecki Employee Right to Know Act, employees generally have the right to review their personnel records, typically up to twice a year, and to submit a written statement disputing something in them. That's one more reason to keep medical information and unrelated notes out of the personnel file, and to write every document as if the employee will read it. They might.

The Gaps I See Most Often

  • Medical notes and FMLA paperwork sitting in the main personnel file.
  • I-9s filed with everything else.
  • No documentation of verbal warnings or performance conversations.
  • Job descriptions that are missing, or haven't been updated since the role changed.
  • No signed acknowledgment for the current version of the handbook.
  • Records for former employees kept forever, or destroyed too early.

How Long to Keep Things

Retention periods vary by document type. Payroll records, I-9s, and leave records each have their own federal requirements, and Michigan's Earned Sick Time Act requires you to keep records of hours worked and sick time used for at least three years. A simple retention schedule, written down once, saves a lot of guessing.

The Real Point

Clean files aren't about bureaucracy. They're about being able to answer a question, defend a decision, or get through an audit without scrambling. Most of the fix is a one-time cleanup and a simple structure going forward.

If you're not sure what's in your files right now, the free HR Self-Audit is a good place to find out where you stand.

Written By

Jamie Wolf, SHRM-CP, MSHRM

Founder of HR Success Partners. Twenty years of HR across healthcare, manufacturing, tech, and professional services. Supporting employers nationwide from Royal Oak, Michigan.

More About Jamie
Free Tool

Where does your HR actually stand?

Ten questions, about two minutes, no email required. You will get an honest read on your gaps and what to handle first.